General
Scope
This is a collection of important focus areas. The aim of the following pages is to give some guidance on exactly what to instill in students during the relatively short time they are under supervised training.
No two students or mentors are the same, but the below takeaways/pointers should hopefully help mentors and students alike in making the student well equipped for self teaching and self assessment during solo training and after validation.
Training goal
The main goal of training is to form good and safe habits, particularly ones that will be safe and still acceptably efficient when working at max capacity. There is a very natural urge to push for advanced techniques and maximum efficiency, but while discussion and demonstration of these can be a good thing, making them the go-to is not good. A solo student or newly valid controller will normally not have the experience or capacity to push very tight gaps or do minimum separation climb-throughs while also managing other traffic safely.
In short: Don't teach the student to run before they can walk. Once the student is safe and competent and able to self-assess, more advanced techniques can be explored either with guidance or on their own.
When starting the solo training, the student should be very well versed in the below:
- Standard phraseology and good radio discipline.
- Scan & plan, keep looking outwards for the next problem. Normal calls should never come as a surprise, and the response should generally already have been thought out.
- Plan early, but don't marry your plans. If it needs changing, change it.
- Basic controlling techniques. Inventive/advanced techniques should only be experimented with under very low workloads.
- Have a set of "standard techniques" for the control position in order to reduce the mental load of everyday tasks (taxi routings, level assignments, headings) but WITHOUT letting them become automatic responses. They must be adjusted as required, and it is often required to do so.
- Base all decisions on logic. A controller should never do or say anything "just because" they've seen or heard it somewhere or been told to do it by someone. The student must understand fully why they say and do things, not just what to say and do.
- Manage workload well (see relevant section below)
- Always look for the next job. Do things now rather than later. It's easy for students and low experience controllers to get hung up on things or to relax too much in quiet periods, they need to make a habit of looking for problems and solving them ahead of time, without getting stuck. Once the student starts getting the hang of the basics, prompt them constantly to do the next thing without necessarily specifying what that is.
Take over early, demonstrate good techniques
When student's completely lose control, their confidence will take a big hit. While seeing how bad things can go can be interesting, it's far more beneficial to take over early and demonstrate good techniques.
In addition, it inconveniences pilots when students lose the plot, so avoid this and keep the traffic moving.
If it's taken over early rather than late, you have the chance to talk through what you're doing and provide very good learning. If everything goes wrong first, the student is likely more focused on feeling bad than learning.
As an instructor, trying to fix a traffic scenario that has already gone bad is very challenging and likely to cause problems, so take it early.
Don't get too involved in other sectors
It's a team effort, controllers are cogs in a machine. If too much energy is spent on getting involved with other sectors, your own traffic will suffer and everyone gets annoyed at you.
Resolve situation before transferring aircraft
Don't transfer a conflict unless it is clear that the next sector is better equipped to manage it and it has been well coordinated.
Managing workload
It is shockingly easy as a controller to create high workload scenarios with relatively few planes involved. This is generally done in the name of expedition, and because trying to be expeditious is in the nature of good controlling it is a very common human factor error.
Complex scenarios leads to tunnel-vision, drastically increasing the chances of missing other problems in the sector. New controllers don't have the experience and muscle memory seasoned controllers have built up for normal traffic, and therefore should worry more (more, not exclusively) about safety than advanced forms of expedition.
A couple of points to consider:
-
Use red carpet taxi techniques in high workload or for longer distances / many taxiways. Stopping short of a taxiway for a minute unnecessarily is far better than an all-the-way clearance turning into a collison.
-
Climbing via the SID is almost always going to be safe against inbounds (particularly in merge point airspaces) when inbounds and outbounds are following the procedure's vertical profile, while issuing directs early will easily require awkward level restrictions or turns to avoid conflict with inbounds.
-
Gambling on aircraft performance to achieve vertical separation or clearing MVA/airspace boundaries, coordinating non-standard directs, accepting any and all training/non-standard request, and all other types of techniques that requires a larger amount of thought/focus/monitoring are OK to demonstrate and teach as posibilities for quiet moments of course, but it must be impressed that these are NOT to be the go-to solution but instead carefully considered and applied only when appropriate.
-
Sacrifice some efficiency and use of advanced/non-standard techniques when workload requires, and keeping things predictable for both pilots and controllers. Avoid last minute changes, tight radar circuits, convoluted taxi instructions.
-
Don't say yes to everything. Training and non-standard traffic can and must be delayed or turned away when normal traffic loads are high. Noone has the right to do IFR/VFR circuits. Offer alternatives and delay information as appropriate.
Use the tools well
Euroscope and its plugins has lots of features that can dramatically increase situational awareness and prevent forgetting things. Particularly highlighting tags as a simple remind-me (only shown in own client) and use of the remarks field (shown to all ATC) goes a long way in increasing SA.
And remind them that you never know who's observing or watching a stream, so don't write anything that breaks CoC.
Radio discipline
Poor radio management is the easiest way of tanking capacity. Managing the radio well is critical for safe and competent controlling, particularly at high workloads.
Refer to the radio discipline basics
Anticipating the next call
Once the basics are mastered, a neat scan/plan technique is to anticipate who will call you next, and what they will say. Experienced controllers do this all the time, but students will usually require prompting to make it a habit. Typical clues include track handoff, 7000 squawks approaching zone boundary, minutes lapsed since push was started, time at holdingpoint doing run-ups, distance to go vs further descend, etc.
Urgent/emergency instructions
These should be well known by all controllers, and all students should be able to say them correctly without hesitation:
- Avoiding action: "CALLSIGN, avoiding action, turn [right/left] immediately heading xxx" - followed by traffic call: "Traffic was X o clock..."
- TCAS RA: Following a resolution advisory (not TA - traffic advisory), ATC must not issue any avoiding action. The only response should be "Roger", and further instructions should only be issued after the pilot has reported "clear of conflict".
- Terrain Awareness System: If a pilot reports to be responding to any terrain awareness systems, such as GPWS, the controller should only respond with and acknowledgement and the QNH setting: "CALLSIGN, roger, QNH 1001".